Login

  • SU Directory
  • Trading
  • NUS Extra

News

Bursaries and fee waivers: the facts

Rated 5/5 (1 person). Log in to rate.

The issue:

Fee waivers do not actually give the student anything at all unless a student goes on to be successful in a well-paid job, by which time they will not need a retrospective discount on their higher education degree. Students need money when they are studying, they don’t need a ‘discount’ that they will likely never see the benefit of.

The £7,500 threshold to get into the auction for the 20,000 margin places, created by taking 8% off institutions (excluding AAB students) has meant that institutions have sacrificed access spend on bursaries so they can offer partial fee waivers. Owing to the repayment mechanism of loans (9% over £21,000 for 30 years), only high earners will ever earn enough to realise that fee waiver - by government’s own figures, 40% will never repay enough for a small fee waiver to become a reality. The government has created a system to force institutions to lower their fees (because they can’t afford not to) by conning students into thinking they’re getting
money off fees, when in reality they're not – and they lose out on the upfront cash in hand support that bursaries would provide.


The impact we want:
The way that government proposes to give financial support to the most disadvantaged people is a mess. Fee waivers are a con as they yield virtually no benefit whatsoever to the majority of students. We want fee waivers to be banned as a feature of the Access Agreement.

Widening participation is meaningless unless the support is available to make higher education affordable at the point of study, and we want students to benefit from the right support, reducing drop-outs.


The outcome we want:
We need MPs to put as much scrutiny as possible on David Willetts, to force him to come clean that he’s conning students, and ultimately to take fee waivers out of the calculation of 'average fee level' when calculating the £7,500 threshold for the auction.
We want fee waivers to be banned unless they represent at least 50% of the entire fee (the only point at which they start to possibly benefit students in the future), and even then we want assurances that real cash-in-hand support will be available to all students that need it, to a level capable of sustaining them.


Our targets:

  • Vice-Chancellors who share our views about the pounds in students’ pockets can be strong public allies if they are willing to speak out about this.
  • Both the Higher Education Funding Council for England and the Office for Fair Access have taken no view on the suitability or otherwise of fee waivers. Presenting these with evidence may encourage them to take a line on bursaries over fee waivers.
  • MPs can ask BIS and its Ministers to report on the effectiveness or otherwise of fee waivers or bursaries. Too often the justification for fee waivers is that bursaries have shown no impact on recruitment. We need to make it clear that our point is about retention. MPs will care about the welfare of their constituents and support us in making this case to government.

Our campaign actions:

  • What is your VC/ Principal’s view on bursaries and fee waivers? If they haven’t already taken a public view, persuade them to do so. If they take the same position as you, stand on a joint platform – make a joint statement and promote it – and make sure your MP knows about it.
  • Give your MP some key facts about how this policy is impacting on your institution, e.g. how much the institution has reduced its bursary budget by, and gather feedback from current students receiving bursaries about whether they think they would be more likely to drop out had they only been granted a fee waiver rather than a bursary. You can then ask your MP to take action by:
  •            Writing to the Minister, David Willetts
  •            asking parliamentray questions on the issue, for example:

“Does the Minister believe it is fair that [your institution] was forced to reduce the amount of bursaries offered to new students by £[XX]m and instead now offer £[XX]m of partial fee waivers, when he knows that these fee waivers mean nothing unless the graduate becomes a high earner, whereas bursaries offer cash to those most in need?”

Comments

Please login to comment.

No comments have been made.
 
Some features of this site - including article viewing - require javascript enabled.
You must be logged in to view this article - Login now

Share

Latest in campaigns

Immigration Bill Update

Update on the immigration bill, outlining what is currently happening with landlord checks, NHS charges and appeal rights.

 
Community Organising in Students’ Unions

Presenting Ideas for the Innovation Fund, Dot Kirk explains how community organising has developed at Brighton Students' Union.

 
Mental Health Training

NUS Scotland can provide Scotland's Mental Health First Aid training and other mental health training and workshops to colleges and universities.

 
Student Leader congratulates students on results and encourages them to use careers guidance

NUS-USI President Rebecca Hall has praised students in Northern Ireland on their A-Level results and has said that anyone unsure of their next steps people should seek careers guidance about their education or career plans. She also called on the Employment and Learning Minister to consider increasing student grants and maintenance loans in line with inflation on an annual basis, within the current review of higher education to help higher education students make ends meet.

 
International Students Delays and Deportations

NUS has been made aware that there are a significant number of students being detained and deported over the recent investigation into questionable English language tests with a company called ETS. These students come from universities and colleges across the UK but we have not been given a list of exactly where.

 
Save the AS level

NUS has launched a campaign calling for a full reversal of the decoupling of the AS and A level, allowing students to take an AS level as part of their full A level qualification.

 
 

Latest news

University students warned to stay vigilant amidst suspected mobile phone fraud

The National Mobile Phone Crime Unit (NMPCU) has launched an investigation into a suspected mobile phone fraud targeting students at universities across the UK.

 
Hot Seat: Camila Batmanghelidjh

Camila Batmanghelidjh CBE has founded two charities, Kids Company and Place2Be, and works to support vulnerable children throughout the UK. She talks to Spotlight about her work, dealing with challenges and what inspires her.

 
Globalising the student experience

More and more students are choosing to spend time abroad as part of a course, while a large number of foreign students continue to come to the UK each year. Catherine Thwaites, NUS Scotland international education officer, explains how the student experience is going global.

 
Bouncing back...

Aberdeen University Students’ Association picked up the award for ‘Most Improved Employee Engagement’ at NUS Convention 2014. Their story is a compelling account of how a difficult situation can be turned around into something positive, as Claire Marsland, NUS HR senior consultant, explains.

 
Getting staff satisfaction

How many of the staff at your organisation would recommend it as a great place to work?
At Nottingham Trent Students’ Union, it’s 97 per cent! And, with an overall engagement score of 98 per cent, they won the award for ‘Highest Employee Engagement’ at NUS Convention 2014, as NUS HR senior consultant Claire Marsland explains.

 
Colum McGuire: From good to great - changing minds and changing lives

NUS vice president (welfare) Colum McGuire talks about student welfare in the movement and in society as the post approaches its 40th anniversary.

 
 

Most Read

Trending/Most Shared articles

 

Recent Comments