Login

  • SU Directory
  • Interact
  • Trading
  • NUS Extra

Blogs

Dannie Grufferty

Dannie Grufferty
Dannie Grufferty is NUS Vice President (Society and Citizenship).

Why Alfie Meadows' trial this week could be a defining moment

This week I attended the trial of Alfie Meadows, a student charged with violent disorder on the infamous night he almost died in the Parliament Kettle during the £9k fees vote in Westminster.

While Alfie is being charged with violent disorder, I have yet to hear of any charges being made against the officer accused of violence towards him. Whatever your view of the debate about ‘peaceful’ protest, the right to protest is under attack and the use of total policing that day was in my view disproportionate.

Alfie’s trial will I think be a defining moment for the fight for our right to protest. We should see it as a political move by the Justice system to use Alfie as some kind of example. When hundreds of students received letters before 9 December demo last year, warning them of the possible use of rubber bullets on the day, and urging them to ‘stay at home’ it has become clear that all avenues are being used to silence us.

It was rather strange for me to sit in the courtroom this week and hear from the Commander who was responsible for establishing the two police cordons set up on Whitehall that dark day on 9 December 2010.

I can’t for obvious reasons, comment on the Commander’s cross-examination in the courtroom, but it was interesting for me to hear his reasons for creating the two police cordons on that day, as I ended up getting stuck in the middle of them!

I had just been in the House of Commons meeting with my MP to lobby him on how he was going to vote that day. He’s a Tory so you could argue it was a bit of a wasted trip. In all fairness though, any excuse to pass through Westminster Hall, site of many happenings, including King Charles I’s sentencing to death.

We exited through the back passage through Portcullis House to find a bit of drama outside with a massive kettle on parliament square. There was a police cordon blocking off parliament square so we decided to walk down Whitehall towards Trafalgar to escape. We were too late. Before we knew it a police cordon was pushing its way from Trafalgar Square up Whitehall, thus creating another kettle (or ‘containment’ as the Met call it) on top of the one already on Parliament square. This time however the police were on horseback and were coming right at us.

We were gradually pushed (alongside a few tourists outside Downing Street) towards Parliament square and eventually kettled for over 5 hours in sub-zero temperatures. And all because I left Parliament through the back entrance!

I then had a photo taken of me when exiting the square, which was clearly absolutely necessary. Even the IPCC believe kettles are a breach of our human right, and we will continue our work to try get them banned. But more importantly right now, think about all the students recently sent down for protesting. Take Frank Fernie from Sheffield Hallam who dreamed of being a social worker since he was young, and has been told, now he’s been charged with violent disorder (for throwing a bit of plywood), that he can no longer be a social worker. Whether he should have thrown that light piece of wood is not really the debate here, it’s the fact that he has had his aspirations stamped upon for it.

Let’s hope there’s a different outcome for Alfie.

Comments

Please login to comment.

Dannie Grufferty
8:32pm on 10 May 12 Oops, thanks Joe!
Joe Armer
12:39pm on 15 Apr 12 Great piece Dannie. Just for clarification, Frankie Fernie was a York College Student who was planning on going to Sheffield Hallam after he'd finished his A-levels

'The views and opinions expressed in these blogs are those of the individual author and do not necessarily reflect the policies and practices of NUS

Share

Blogroll

Liam Burns

Liam Burns
Liam Burns is the President of the National Union of Students (NUS).

36 posts
Last post 08 May 2013
Last comment 05 Apr 2013
Toni Pearce

Toni Pearce
Toni Pearce is the Vice President (Further Education)

17 posts
Last post 29 Apr 2013
Last comment 20 Sep 2012
Vicki Baars

Vicki Baars
Vicki Baars is the NUS Vice President (Union Development).

15 posts
Last post 17 May 2013
Last comment 15 Aug 2012
Dannie Grufferty

Dannie Grufferty
Dannie Grufferty is NUS Vice President (Society and Citizenship).

23 posts
Last post 28 May 2013
Last comment 09 Aug 2012
Rachel Wenstone

Rachel Wenstone is the NUS Vice President (Higher Education).

8 posts
Last post 04 Mar 2013
Pete Mercer

Peter Mercer
Pete Mercer is the NUS Vice President (Welfare).

10 posts
Last post 24 May 2013
Aaron Kiely

Aaron Kiely is the NUS Black Students' Officer.

15 posts
Last post 23 May 2013
Finn McGoldrick

Finn McGoldrick is the NUS LGBT Officer (Women's Place).

4 posts
Last post 12 Dec 2012
Hannah Paterson

Hannah Paterson is the NUS Disabled Students' Officer.

25 posts
Last post 20 Apr 2013
Last comment 03 Dec 2012
Sky Yarlett

Sky Yarlett is the NUS LGBT Officer (Open Place).

8 posts
Last post 15 Jan 2013
Kelley Temple

Kelly Temple

Kelley Temple is the National Women's Officer.

11 posts
Last post 12 Jun 2013
Daniel Stevens

Daniel Stevens is the NUS International Students' Officer.

11 posts
Last post 27 Mar 2013
Last comment 10 Aug 2012
Robin Parker

Robin Parker
Robin Parker is the President of NUS Scotland. 

18 posts
Last post 15 May 2013
Graeme Kirkpatrick

Graeme Kirkpatrick is the Depute President of NUS Scotland.

4 posts
Last post 14 Mar 2013
Stacey Devine

Stacey Devine is the NUS Scotland Women's Officer.

6 posts
Last post 05 Jun 2013
Last comment 08 Sep 2012
Stephanie Lloyd

Stephanie Lloyd is the NUS Wales President.

8 posts
Last post 17 Oct 2012
Raechel Mattey

Raechel Mattey
Raechel Mattey is the Deputy President of NUS Wales.

1 post
Last post 30 Mar 2012
Rhiannon Hedge

Rhiannon Hedge is the NUS Wales Women's Officer.

4 posts
Last post 17 Jan 2013
Adrianne Peltz

Adrienne Peltz
Adrianne Peltz is the President of NUS-USI.

0 posts